Forum
A place to discuss topics/games with other webDiplomacy players.
FirstPreviousNextLast
Klaus klauts (1043 D)
Wed 11 Mar UTC
Crashed games
In the "new games" section, there are countless crashed games, going so far, that most games are crashed games. For some reason this always bothers me. Can someone therefore please delete them?
5 replies
Open
gman314 (1016 D)
12 Mar 11 UTC
(+33)
Winning
Oli won.
On Imperial Civilization's off-topic thread (link inside), there was a brief stint of Second to Last Person to Post Wins. Now that the thread is closed, Oli won.
10878 replies
Open
Nuerginator (1109 D)
Wed 11 Mar UTC
Why did my rating go down?
I joined a PPSC game that was nearly over, and ended with 3 supply centers. Since I bet none, why did my rating go down? Shouldn't it go up, since I won 3 points but paid 0 to enter?
4 replies
Open
VengefulPenguin43 (1857 D)
20 Feb 26 UTC
(+2)
Rating issues
Is anyone else having issues with rating? I just finished a game on Empires and Coalitions and dropped 150 points despite being part of a 4-way draw. Would love to hear if this is just a me problem, or if other people are experiencing this.
it's not updating correctly it seems. the rating is stuck at a certain level, and current rating points are completely based on the most recent results
and if you check the vPoint rating page in your profile, certain games are listed as AncMed with the title "CongratulationsLawton" it seems
Well, isn't that just great, so, don't finish any games for the time being?
you still get the vdip coins, just not the rating updates
vlgambini (1598 D)
21 Feb 26 UTC
As far as that Empire and Coalitions game, it looks like the problem was largely fixed. Everyone's V-rating seems to have been adjusted appropriately: https://vdiplomacy.net/hof.php?gameID=65629

However, that game doesn't show up on yours or anyone's hof scorecard: https://vdiplomacy.net/hof.php?userID=25143
vlgambini (1598 D)
21 Feb 26 UTC
It looks like the same thing happened with this Classic game: https://vdiplomacy.net/hof.php?gameID=65647
vlgambini (1598 D)
21 Feb 26 UTC
This one too:
https://vdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=65913#gamePanel
https://vdiplomacy.net/hof.php?gameID=65913
The ratings are adjusting correctly, but the ratings change isn't displaying correctly on the game panel or on the players' hof scorecards.
Krzysztof1410 (1827 D)
21 Feb 26 UTC
Maybe an integer overflow has happened somewhere (for example on "every point ever given sum" but idk why would anyone have such variable xD) because this site may use short integers due to being old...
JBFroome (1144 D)
23 Feb 26 UTC
I definitely had this issue.

https://www.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=65446#gamePanel

Went from 1296 to 1072 for -224. I am understandable upset because I am new to the site. I had a huge WTA solo for a big win only to draw and lose all my points.
I think this issue might be that I joined the game in which I drew (link above) before the game of my WTA solo (link below) but my WTA solo ended before my other draw. My guess is there was some kind of time stamp sandwich where my rating was adjusted from my original 1000 rather than my rating of 1296 at the time of the draw.

https://www.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=65442#gamePanel
JBFroome (1144 D)
23 Feb 26 UTC
Also, I gained no rating from this game:
https://www.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=65590#gamePanel
vlgambini (1598 D)
26 Feb 26 UTC
The ratings issue has morphed again. What I said earlier is no longer true. Now, there are a handful of games that are just not factoring into people's V-ratings. The three games I linked in my earlier posts are examples of this.
https://vdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=65913
https://vdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=65647
https://vdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=65629

There are other examples. Fortunately, most games don't seem to have this issue. But, the V-ratings are now incorrect for a good number of people.
vlgambini (1598 D)
Sat 09 PM UTC
(+3)
I have a hypothesis of what is happening with V-ratings. It seems that for games with a gameID above a certain number, the V-rating feature no longer works correctly. That number appears to be gameID=65535. For games with gameID= any number less than 65535, the V-rating seems to still work. I highly doubt it's a coincidence that this cutoff number 65535 is equal to 1 less than 2^16. Maybe this will be meaningful to folks who understand software coding.

For games with gameID above the magic number, the V-rating still *sort of* works, at least temporarily. It seems we all now have a correctly calculated and essentially frozen permanent V-rating that takes into account only games with gameID=65534 or lower. When you finish a game with gameID=65536 or higher, the V-rating system does in fact kick in, and adjusts your V-rating ... but that adjustment only lasts until you finish another game with gameID=65536 or higher. The V-rating system then calculates a new V-rating based on your frozen, permanent V-rating, adjusted by only the results of that one, most recently finished 65536+ game. The effects of the previous 65536+ finished game is erased from having any effect on your V-rating.

Folks who are currently playing in active games with gameID less than 65535 could test this hypothesis. See what happens to your V-rating when the game ends. I would expect your V-rating to adjust normally, and permanently, based on the outcome.

Finally, a word about gameID=65535. It's gone. It no longer exists. I have a feeling it was the game @CoffeeAndKeyboards mentioned, Congratulations Lawton!, that game apparently made the system go haywire when it ended.
AivenSycamore (846 D)
Sat 10 PM UTC
There was one I was in where I think I gained too much!! But only slightly... (Not like it matters too much, seeing how few I have lmao)
Krzysztof1410 (1827 D)
Sun 11 AM UTC
(+1)
It is of course very close to the upper bound of 16-bit integer
Krzysztof1410 (1827 D)
Sun 11 AM UTC
(+1)
And it is highly likely that they use those


15 replies
butterhead (1391 D)
21 May 12 UTC
(+19)
Advertise your NON-live games here!
In an effort to compromise the pro-ads versus anti-ads for games: Post here for your non-live games to cut down on the number of ads but still advertise games. Post game link, WTA or PPSC, and the bet. Note: this doesn't count for special rules games.
3569 replies
Open
MagicalSand (1876 D)
17 Feb 26 UTC
(+1)
Europa Renavito team game but color coded
Call me crazy, but I have an idea. Ive seen team games done on this map before and they are pretty fun. So I thought up a unique twist to it, all the teams are color coded! (Mostly)

So i went and spent an hour putting together a rough idea to what it could be. 6 teams, relatively evenly spread out, and coded to colors with a few exceptions. Afterall where do you put Morocco the only orange country?
52 replies
Open
kaner406 (2247 D Mod (B))
08 Sep 18 UTC
(+7)
Variant Development Thread
This thread is made for the express purpose of cutting down of multiple threads that deal with new variants, ideas, concepts etc...
1212 replies
Open
Higher Rated Games
I'm curious if anyone would want to run some games through this thread of people with higher ratings? There's no real way to screen for it on anonymous games, and I feel like it would make for generally better games.

If this is against some sort of equal play law on this site, no worries at all, just wanted to see if there was any interest, and if so, what maps people wanted?
18 replies
Open
Heer Alvaro (1000 D)
Wed 04 Mar UTC
Middle East on War
Hi, Years ago I created a Map called “Middle East on War”. But this map is not working fully well because wasn’t created correctly.

Can someone help me to create 100% correctly this map?
4 replies
Open
David Hood (976 D)
Thu 05 Mar UTC
(+1)
February Deadline News Just Released
Latest Episode of Deadline News is out from the Diplomacy Broadcast Network. In this edition we have a promo interview about the upcoming World Dipcon in Greece with TD Spyros Dovas, an interview with UK hobby legend Stephen Agar about a great many things, the annual determination of what is Hot or Not in the hobby with Christopher John Ward, Zoe Cameron, and Randy Lawrence Hurt, and headlines from around the world of Diplomacy.
https://youtu.be/kYbnHM3zGig?si=NLgDQrsKv2opBhl2
0 replies
Open
magician07 (1527 D)
26 Jan 26 UTC
How to report cheating ?
In one of my games, I suspect that two players may be friends or even the same person. Their site registration dates are identical, and they have played the same three games together. How can I report this?
Game: https://www.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=65588
Players: England and Italy
16 replies
Open
Richie_FL (1000 D)
21 Feb 26 UTC
(+4)
I Ranked All The Variants
I thought it would be interesting to compare each map, so I wrote some code, based on the best country's performance minus the worst country's performance, then the biggest difference is ranked lower, while a smaller difference is ranked higher. I spent too much time on it, and now I have a list, check it out!
18 replies
Open
Peppapig (1020 D)
16 Feb 26 UTC
(+1)
Happy Lunar New Year! 新年快乐!
Happy Lunar New Year! 新年快乐!
13 replies
Open
Tdawg37 (1000 D)
18 Feb 26 UTC
Sandbox
Is there any way to make a sandbox on vDip? I can't seem to find it in any menu
1 reply
Open
CoffeeAndKeyboards (1383 D)
15 Feb 26 UTC
(+1)
Congratulations Lawton!
Apparently something to do with the AncMed map
5 replies
Open
vlgambini (1598 D)
27 Jan 26 UTC
Awake
vDip is hosting the diplomacy version of "Awake," the 2019 Netflix game show! Details below.
14 replies
Open
AivenSycamore (846 D)
13 Nov 25 UTC
Diplomacy Variant Creation
So I've been in the process of making a Diplomacy Variant. I plan to take the "Europa Renovatio" map and update and expand it. (What I mean to say is, because it's a translation of the EU4 map, it's gone out of date since then.)
21 replies
Open
eatheavymetal (965 D)
09 Feb 26 UTC
Divided States Game
Hey, I am advetising this Divided States game. It's over half full right now, but we still need a lot more players. Global and individual chat is on for this game.

https://www.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=65731
3 replies
Open
Specialweek (2652 D)
30 Jan 26 UTC
About the Colonial 1885 version
Due to the map info it says that the Caspian Sea is a passible place, so it seems that the only possible case is that Russia build a fleet at Orenburg and move it into the Caspian sea. But have anyone ever seen a fleet there? Just curious.
3 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
05 Feb 26 UTC
1 hour turns
https://www.vdiplomacy.com/board.php?gameID=65662#gamePanel

I know we arent supposed to talk about ongoing games really, but since this game is a gun boat, this is the only way to do so. Anyways someone made a gunboat game with 1 hour turns... if your in it please vote cancel, cause we all have to sleep eventually right? And once we do, we'll get booted from the game
0 replies
Open
Migraine (857 D)
01 Feb 26 UTC
Thoughts on Gobble-Earth
Not really anything specific, just wondering what most people think of the variant. I know it’s not well-balanced, but to be honest there are much worse variants out there.
3 replies
Open
Flame (1073 D)
17 Jan 26 UTC
(+1)
Napoleonic Redux Variant
Hi!!! What about to do a REDUX-variation for Napoleonic? With neutrals powers (sc) and possibly holding neutral units? It will be very interesting,I suppose. I have already written to the author Firehawk. Let's see what he will answer. And do you think about this idea?
4 replies
Open
The Treaty of Verdun
I've heard that it is incredibly hard to make a good map for around three players for instance, the 1066 makes the Norwegians so powerful but somehow the 843: Treaty of Verdun seems like it is almost perfectly balanced. How is this possible? Looking at the map it is quite hard to see symmetry but yet it still works. What makes the Treaty of Verdun different?
11 replies
Open
CoffeeAndKeyboards (1383 D)
22 Jan 26 UTC
(+1)
Rat Wars Addiction
Please someone just cure my rat wars addiction I can't stop playing Rat Wars it's my weekly fix of dopamine at this point
12 replies
Open
Rock Stone (1054 D)
26 Jan 26 UTC
Playing against bots
I read the Help section on this but can't seem to find where I choose to play against bots. Any help appreciated.
1 reply
Open
David Hood (976 D)
24 Jan 26 UTC
January 2026 Deadline News from DBN
January 2026 edition of Deadline News from the Diplomacy Broadcast Network has just been released. Check out an interview with DBN producer Hal Schild about his work for the network behind the scenes, the yearly check-in with NADF President Katie Gray about the state of the hobby in North America, and headlines from around the world of Diplomacy.
https://youtu.be/Tan0OdhZDw8?si=EnhM1ieRkr0Bfj8M
0 replies
Open
Nuerginator (1109 D)
22 Jan 26 UTC
Missing/Lost Three Kingdoms Map?
According to the Wikipedia page for Diplomacy, there was supposedly a variant called "Diplomacy of the Three Kingdoms". Based on the Three Kingdoms in Ancient China, it was created by Edi Birsan to introduce the basic ideas of the main game to a Chinese audience with a setting more close to their own historical experience. I can't find this game online, and the map isn't on this site. I was wondering if anyone knew where I could play it!
3 replies
Open
JBFroome (1144 D)
03 Jan 26 UTC
Game Limits and Hot Join
Hello all,
I am new to the platform but I long time Diplomacy Enjoyer. I noticed that I can only join 2 new games having played less than 20 phases. But there does not seem to be a limit to the number of open positions I am allowed to join. Is this intentional?
I appreciate the opportunity to join more games and increase my phases played, but I want to know if I will be able to join more new games once I reach the 20 phase count. Any insight would be appreciated.
7 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
18 Jan 26 UTC
Join Pirates! Bring your own rum!
Six more needed for Pirates! https://vdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=65520
0 replies
Open
Anon (?? D)
18 Jan 26 UTC
Join Pirates! Bring your own rum!
Six more needed for Pirates! https://vdiplomacy.net/board.php?gameID=65520
0 replies
Open
FirstPreviousNextLast
Back to top